Ben Nye cake liner vs Bobbi Brown Gel liner

I normal always use Ben Nye cake eye liner in black when I'm doing make up on people, as its easy to use just add water and gives a natural line. You can put a few layers of the product on it get a deeper colour.

This time I decided to try out Bobbi Browns Gel eye liner in black ink this time. It glided onto the eye and gave a really intense glossy finish. Really intense colour which I wanted for the look I was working on.The only bad think about it was when I went to take the make up off my model and start on a new look, it took a long time to get off.
But after using this I don't think I would go back to the Ben Nye Cake liner. I just need to find a better eye make up remover! I'm looking forward to buying a  chocolate brown colour in this range.